I used to use Danielle's Place when my kids were younger. They had a lot of free stuff then plus extra for subscriber's--I'm not sure what's available for free vs. pay now but I really liked it.
If you're wanting stuff that's already pre-cut and such, don't forget to check Oriental Trading for some cute Bible crafts. My husband uses stuff from there for his 3rd and 4th graders, and our church's preschool uses their stuff a lot as well. And I second Danielle's Place as a good resource. She has some really cute stuff there.
I second Oriental Trading. Their Bible crafts are so GREAT! We used them for our VBS all the time. Their prices are reasonable and have great things on sale so stock up for next year!
Bible Story Mini Books http://www.christianpreschoolprintables.com/MiniBooks.html Bible ABC's Writing Sheets and Coloring Pages http://www.christianpreschoolprintables.com/BibleColoringPages.html Thanksgiving Bible Crafts http://www.christianpreschoolprintables.com/Thanksgiving.html Bible Crafts http://www.christianpreschoolprintables.com/NewCraftandWorkshet.html 4 Pages of File Folder Printable Games http://www.christianpreschoolprintables.com/ChristianFileFolderGames.html